search expand

“Arabs and Muslims should be wary of anthropologists”

News of anthropologists in the US. military starts circulating on one of the largest Muslim websites, Culture Matters reports. Anthropologist Donald Abdallah Cole says to IslamOnline.net that “Arabs and Muslims should be wary of western anthropologists”:

‘We should be wary of everything that is written about us, whether by local people or by foreigners. To be wary does not mean to reject. We need to read what anthropologists say about people in the developing world and what they say about Islam and Muslims,’ he explained.

‘We can expect to trust the reliability of professional academic anthropologists who are subject to peer review and evaluation. But for others who are not fully professional, we need to be more careful.’”

>> read the whole story on Culture Matters

This reaction is no surprise, especially when we remember that Britian has recruited anthropologists for spying on muslims.

A few weeks ago anthropologist Maximilan Forte wrote that if anthropology’s role as an instrument of empire can come back into sharper focus it is no wonder that anthropology is banished from universities in the ‘decolonized’ world”.

Over at Savage Minds, a dscussion is going on if all this focus on anthropology in the Iraq war is primarily a PR game to bolster the image that the military is doing something novel to correct the errors of the Iraq occupation.

News of anthropologists in the US. military starts circulating on one of the largest Muslim websites, Culture Matters reports. Anthropologist Donald Abdallah Cole says to IslamOnline.net that "Arabs and Muslims should be wary of western anthropologists":

‘We should be wary…

Read more

New fieldwork blog: Struggling with antipathy for the field and “anthropology-fed-up-ness”

Norwegian anthropologist Jon Henrik Ziegler Remme has started blogging. He is currently on fieldwork in the Philippines among the Pentecostal Christians in Ifugao.

In his first two posts of his blog Jon Henrik in Ifugao, he describes parts of the fieldwork process that are familiar for most anthropologists but that rarely make it into papers or monograps: “anthropology-fed-up-ness” and antipathy for the field.

“Back in Ifugao, the first thing that struck me was that I was already tired of being here”, he writes in his first post Chasing Ifugao Christians with a lack of motivation….

“One of the main impressions I had of my previous fieldwork was that this type of research is very inefficient. (…) Today I had such an experience again”, he writes in his second post When the time is right…

>> visit Jon Henrik Ziegler Remme’s blog

For information on his first research project, see the project website.

SEE ALSO:

On fieldwork: “Blogging sharpens the attention”

Paper by Erkan Saka: Blogging as a Research Tool for Ethnographic Fieldwork

antropologi.info survey: Six anthropologists on Anthropology and Internet

Anthropology blogs

Norwegian anthropologist Jon Henrik Ziegler Remme has started blogging. He is currently on fieldwork in the Philippines among the Pentecostal Christians in Ifugao.

In his first two posts of his blog Jon Henrik in Ifugao, he describes parts of…

Read more

Unni Wikan: Ved å støtte koranskolene støtter man fundamentalistisme

Bistandsaktuelt fortsetter debatten om norsk støtte til koranskoler i Pakistan. I den ferske utgaven 8/2007 får vi vite at antropolog Unni Wikan, er sterkt kritisk til at Norge støtter koranskoler (madrasaer) i Nord-Vest-provinsen:

– Dette er fundamentalistiske indoktringeringsanstalter. Nord-Vest-provinsen er stokk fundamentalistisk. Ved å støtte disse koranskolene bygger man opp under fundamentalistiske lærere, og gir dem en sterkere posisjon.

Wikan mener at norske myndigheter burde lytte til den pakistanske advokaten og menneskerettighetsaktivisten Asma Jahangir som fikk UiOs menneskerettspris i 2002:

– Da jeg traff henne på en konferanse for noen år siden, var hun sterkt kritisk til at Norge støtter koranskoler. Hun sa da at ledelsen ved madrasaene etter hennes mening gir inntrykk av å være mer moderate for å få pengestøtte, mens de fleste i virkeligheten er fundamentalister. Jeg regner Jahangir som svært kunnskapsrik, og mener Norge burde se seg om etter alternative miljøer å støtte.

Men meningene er delte her og Kees van den Bosch, en forsker som “kjenner godt det norskstøttede utdanningsprosjektet i Nord-Vest-provinsen”, mener mye av den informasjonen som er kommet fram i media omkring koranskolene som potensielle utklekkingsanstalter for jihad-soldater, er helt feil:

– Det er som å si at norske, religiøse skoler utdanner korsfarere. Madrasaene er normale skoler som pakistanske foreldre mer enn gjerne sender ungene sine til fordi de mener at disse skolene kan gi barna en bedre utdanning enn det offentlige skolesystemet.

>> les hele saken i Bistandsaktuelt

Debatten begynte i forrige nummer av Bistandsaktuelt, se Bør Norge gi støtte til koranskoler?. Saken ble så tatt opp av Dagsavisen, se Norge støtter omstridte koranskoler i Pakistan

Bistandsaktuelt fortsetter debatten om norsk støtte til koranskoler i Pakistan. I den ferske utgaven 8/2007 får vi vite at antropolog Unni Wikan, er sterkt kritisk til at Norge støtter koranskoler (madrasaer) i Nord-Vest-provinsen:

– Dette er fundamentalistiske indoktringeringsanstalter. Nord-Vest-provinsen er…

Read more

Now online: Up to 100 year old anthropology papers

(via Museum Anthropology) More and more open access to anthropology online: The American Museum of Natural History has digitalized their up to 100 year old Anthropological Papers and put them online.

We find both more recent papers like Green revolution : agricultural and social change in a north Indian village and (that’s maybe even more interesting) historic ethnographies from the beginning of the 20th century like Some protective designs of the Dakota by Clark Wissler (published 1907), Tales of Yukaghir, Lamut, and Russanized natives of eastern Siberia by Waldemar Bogoras (published 1918) and The history of Philippine civilization as reflected in religious nomenclature by Alfred L. Kroeber (published 1918).

>> browse the whole collection

SEE ALSO:

2006 – The Year of Open Access Anthropology?

(via Museum Anthropology) More and more open access to anthropology online: The American Museum of Natural History has digitalized their up to 100 year old Anthropological Papers and put them online.

We find both more recent papers like Green…

Read more

AfricaWrites – Videos from rural Africa

Patrick Gorham, editor of AfricaWrites: Heroes, Rituals & Legends writes to me. He created AfricaWrites several years ago “with the intent and goals of research, exploration, preservation and documentation of traditional African culture”. On the website you can watch several videos from rural Africa.

>> visit AfricaWrites.com

>> Ugotrade.com with more info on AfricaWrites

Patrick Gorham, editor of AfricaWrites: Heroes, Rituals & Legends writes to me. He created AfricaWrites several years ago "with the intent and goals of research, exploration, preservation and documentation of traditional African culture". On the website you can watch several…

Read more